Legal rules and practices of registration and burial of stillbirths in 19th and 20th century Netherlands

Research output: Chapter in book/volumeChapterScientificpeer-review

Abstract

Perinatal mortality rates have been widely used and misused as indicators of
social advancement, public health, and the quality of maternal and antenatal
care1. They figure prominently in international comparisons or to evaluate the
progress achieved over time within a specific country and have become a matter
of national prestige or shame (Gourbin, Masuy-Stroobant, 1995; Richardus,
Graafmans, Verloove-Vanhorick, Mackenbach, 1998). The construction of
these figures is very dependent on precise legal definitions of the concerned
vital events, on variations in local practices of declaration and on systems of
health care and registration. Stillbirths are an important component of perinatal
mortality. To do justice to the historical evolution of the term, we here
define stillbirths as both fetuses being born dead and children born alive but
dying before a birth certificate was issued.
Since the introduction of civil registration, many European countries “have
grappled with the issues of how to define and record stillbirths” (Gourdon,
Rollet, 2009). The way in which legislators, municipal functionaries, physicians,
statisticians, and religious authorities in the various countries have dealt
with stillbirths in the past might yield important information on the usefulness
of statistical data on perinatal death in the past. It might also be helpful in
informing us about the way in which a society’s opinion on a question such as
“When does life begin?” has evolved. To shed light on the long-term changes
in the way legal, statistical and medical authorities constructed the category of
“stillbirth”, one can make use of official documents containing information on
the registration and handling of the birth, the death and burial procedures for
stillbirths. Laws, by-laws, administrative regulations, and church laws express
the opinions of jurists, representatives and state officials on what constitutes
a stillbirth; they define whether and how the medical profession had to determine whether a live birth and death had occurred and how it should then be
registered; what information on these infants was considered relevant for statistical
analysis; and how local authorities should handle the burial. These official
documents can also lend insight into collective images and how they were
confirmed or disputed, as well as illuminate the fine line between what was
considered socially acceptable and what was considered objectionable. These
sources also shed some light on the ways in which families handled stillbirths.
For more recent periods, such information has been gathered from interviews
with elderly parents whose child had died during pregnancy or shortly after
delivery, and from interviews with retired professionals in the funerary industry,
as well as medical doctors or parents themselves who directly dealt with
pregnancy loss; but this method of data-gathering could not go further back in
time than the mid-1950s (Avis, 2014; Faro, 2015; Peelen, 2011).
Our intention is to present an overview for the Netherlands for stillbirths
occurring in the nineteenth and the first part of the twentieth centuries. Our
study starts around 1810, because until the moment the Dutch Republic was
annexed by France, the absence of a powerful central authority meant there
was no uniform system of civil registration. Rules for the registration of vital
events also varied widely due to the religious diversity of the country (Van der
Woude, 1980). The studies cited above did a fine job of covering changes in the
attitude toward stillbirths in the more recent period (1970-present), so that
period will be treated only very briefly here.

1. The official WHO-definition of perinatal mortality includes two components: stillbirths (babies born with no signs of life at or after 28 weeks’ gestation) and early neonatal deaths (babies dying 0-6 days after birth).
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationMorts avant de naître
Subtitle of host publicationLa mort périnatale
PublisherPresses Universitaires François-Rabelais
Pages141-169
ISBN (Print)978-2-86906-659-5
Publication statusPublished - 2018

Publication series

NameSérie Médecine
PublisherPresses Universitaires François-Rabelais

Fingerprint Dive into the research topics of 'Legal rules and practices of registration and burial of stillbirths in 19th and 20th century Netherlands'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this