What is a Digital Editorial Intervention? On the primacy of syntax in digital scholarly editions, and the limits of digital editorial interventions

Joris J. van Zundert, T.L. Andrews

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperScientificpeer-review

Abstract

The classical form of a scholarly edition—a text, with an accompanying set of annotations that is expressed in the stylized form of a critical apparatus—can easily be seen as text encoding in its own right. Semantic information is encoded in a particular rarefied syntax, which expresses to the philologically literate the editor’s interpretation of, and occasional intervention in, the text. From this perspective, digital text encoding is a natural step: the same expression of editorial interpretation and intervention, already regarded as a formalised language, is translated to a syntax meant to be parsed by a machine. Yet there remains considerable resistance within philology to the adoption of digital editorial methods that move beyond what is essentially an Internet-enabled facsimile of a print edition, and our aim in this paper is to explore why that is the case. One explanation is rooted in the primacy given in machine languages to syntax, compared to the emphasis laid in human language on semantics. Abuse the grammar or rely on a double entendre in a critical apparatus, and your reader will attempt nonetheless to make sense out of what was written. To attempt the same in a computational encoding will almost inevitably produce a parsing error—an immediate and total refusal by the machine to attempt to understand what was meant—which itself removes from the digital user the possibility that the reader of a print edition would have: to perform a re-interpretation, or a second intervention, on the text. In this paper we will discuss how the shift from analogue to digital editing thus also entails a shift in the nature of, and the constraints placed upon, interventions performed by editor and by reader.
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - 2017
EventESTS 2017: Editorial Degrees of Intervention - Alcalá de Henares, Alcalá de Henares, Spain
Duration: 23 Nov 201724 Nov 2017
Conference number: 14
https://textualscholarship.eu/previous-editions/ests-2017/

Conference

ConferenceESTS 2017: Editorial Degrees of Intervention
Country/TerritorySpain
CityAlcalá de Henares
Period23/11/201724/11/2017
Internet address

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'What is a Digital Editorial Intervention? On the primacy of syntax in digital scholarly editions, and the limits of digital editorial interventions'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this