Mortality limits used in wind energy impact assessment underestimate impacts of wind farms on bird populations

Peter Schippers (Co-auteur), Ralph Buij, Alex Schotman, Jana Verboom, Henk van der Jeugd, Eelke Jongejans

Onderzoeksoutput: Bijdrage aan wetenschappelijk tijdschrift/periodieke uitgaveArtikelWetenschappelijkpeer review

9 Citaten (Scopus)
57 Downloads (Pure)


The consequences of bird mortality caused by collisions with wind turbines are increasingly receiving attention. So-called acceptable mortality limits of populations, that is, those that assume that 1%-5% of additional mortality and the potential biological removal (PBR), provide seemingly clear-cut methods for establishing the reduction in population viability.
We examine how the application of these commonly used mortality limits could affect populations of the Common Starling, Black-tailed Godwit, Marsh Harrier, Eurasian Spoonbill, White Stork, Common Tern, and White-tailed Eagle using stochastic density-independent and density-dependent Leslie matrix models.
Results show that population viability can be very sensitive to proportionally small increases in mortality. Rather than having a negligible effect, we found that a 1% additional mortality in postfledging cohorts of our studied populations resulted in a 2%?24% decrease in the population level after 10 years. Allowing a 5% mortality increase to existing mortality resulted in a 9%-77% reduction in the populations after 10 years.
When the PBR method is used in the density-dependent simulations, the proportional change in the resulting growth rate and carrying capacity was species-independent and largely determined by the recovery factor (Fr). When Fr = 1, a value typically used for robust populations, additional mortality resulted in a 50%-55% reduction in the equilibrium density and the resulting growth rate. When Fr = 0.1, used for threatened populations, the reduction in the equilibrium density and growth rate was about 5%.
Synthesis and applications. Our results show that by allowing a mortality increase from wind farm collisions according to both criteria, the population impacts of these collisions can still be severe. We propose a simple new method as an alternative that was able to estimate mortality impacts of age-structured stochastic density-dependent matrix models.
Originele taal-2Engels
Pagina's (van-tot)6274-6287
Aantal pagina's14
TijdschriftEcology and Evolution
Nummer van het tijdschrift13
StatusGepubliceerd - 2020


Duik in de onderzoeksthema's van 'Mortality limits used in wind energy impact assessment underestimate impacts of wind farms on bird populations'. Samen vormen ze een unieke vingerafdruk.

Citeer dit